Guest Reviews
200+ recent stays. One recurring theme:
“We’ll be back.”
Every review below comes from a real guest who stayed in one of our St. Simons Island homes. Here’s what they tell us, and where to find the home that fits your trip.
In their words
What guests talk about most
We read all 209 reviews and counted what came up. Here’s what our guests remember.
Find your kind of trip
Every trip is different. So are our homes.
Real guests, real stays, and the homes that made them.
“We loved being able to invite our whole family and having enough space for everyone to be comfortable. The pool was a great time, but being so close to downtown, parks and restaurants was incredible!”John, September 2026 · Stollaway Retreat
“Location cannot be beat: walkable neighborhood, across the street from a playground, and walking distance to Pier Village.”Tricia and Scott, April 2026 · Into the Mystic
“Perfect size for us with our two goldendoodles. Pretty fenced yard, beautiful living area with fully equipped kitchen. Quiet neighborhood and close to the beach.”Donna, May 2026 · Simone Tranquilla
“Comfortable furniture with lots of storage and living spaces for our party of 14! The view and breeze from the dock made for amazing sunset happy hours!”Christy, July 2025 · The Oak on the River
“Felt right at home the minute we walked in. The house is so colorful and eclectic, our grandchildren described it as magical! Truly a vacation they will never forget.”Vicki, April 2026 · Sunnybrook by the Sea
“Perfect for 3 families! Sunsets from the rooftop deck were amazing. Porches were wonderful for hanging out and even playing mah-jong when it rained.”Analease, July 2025 · Red Cedar
It’s the little things
The details guests didn’t expect
Great homes get you a five-star review. These are the moments that got guests writing paragraphs.
“The wagon and beach chairs made our trips to the beach so much easier.”
Jess · Oak’s End Haven“The kitchen even had kids utensils and plates, which was great for our 5 year old!”
Jess · Oak’s End Haven“We left something really important behind. The staff turned it in and someone graciously shipped it to us.”
Laura · Oak’s End Haven“So thankful for the elevator! Getting luggage and groceries up would have been a real challenge.”
Analease · Red Cedar“For it to allow dogs, you would never even know it by how immaculate the place was.”
Carly · Simone Tranquilla“My favorite feature was the vintage Dutch door. It was beautiful.”
Charla · Oak’s End HavenWe have visited St. Simons Island for over 30 years. This was by far the nicest place we have stayed.Jane, July 2025 · Red Cedar
