Bite Into the Best St Simons Island Pizza

One of the best parts of any vacation is the variety of available food. But sometimes, good old-fashioned comfort food is what you crave. Pizza is the perfect choice for a little taste of home, but with an island flair.

Sal’s Neighborhood Pizzeria

Photo Credit: fredericatrading via Instagram

For comfort food like none other, Sal’s is sure to deliver. Not only does the restaurant offer mouthwatering, cheesy goodness in every bite, you also can’t beat the atmosphere. Owner/operator Sal has a history as a boxer and spent some time working in four-star restaurants in New York before opening his pizzeria on St. Simons — and it shows.

The Marshall/FLETC is one of the pizzeria’s bestsellers. Sal’s has won diners’ hearts for years with an extensive menu, full bar, and excellent ambiance. 

Mellow Mushroom

Photo Credit: mellowmushroom via Instagram

A quirky yet exciting choice for pizza is Mellow Mushroom. The restaurant’s stone-baked pizzas offer a variety of options sure to satisfy even the pickiest eater. The pizzas all have psychedelic names for a bit of added fun, and they taste out of this world.

With the unique MontAmoré® cheese from Wisconsin, the Holy Shiitake Pie is worth stopping in to enjoy. Mellow Mushroom is a pricier option for pizza, but the quality is otherworldly.

V Pizza

Photo Credit: v_pizzeria via Instagram

There’s no reason to sacrifice healthy choices while vacationing, and V Pizza makes it easy to get your comfort food fix while staying true to your dietary needs. With some of the best gluten-free pizza around, V Pizza provides flavor, variety, and quality.

Gluten-free or cauliflower crust pairs perfectly with Pizza Margherita, the restaurant’s signature pie. Vegetarian options pepper the menu, and with prices that won’t break the bank, V Pizza is sure to be a hit.

Fox’s Pizza Den

Photo Credit: foxspizzaoconee via Instagram

When cheesy tomato goodness is on your list, look no further than Fox’s Pizza Den. As a franchise operation, you might find this one in your own backyard. 

There’s something for everyone on the menu with standard pies and specialty recipes such as the Chicken Rancher and Bacon Double Cheeseburger pizzas. The price is right, the flavor’s great, and your family will beg to come back for more.

CJ’s Italian Restaurant

Photo Credit: cjs_italian via Instagram

For some BBQ to soothe your soul, look no farther than the Southern BBQ pie at CJ’s Italian Restaurant. Homemade crust, hand-picked ingredients, and a special connection with the community make CJ’s one of the best pizzerias around. 

To spread some philanthropic love while satisfying your appetite, try Noah’s Pizza. The restaurant donates a portion of the proceeds from this pizza to send families of kids with cancer to a beach camp. And that’s just the beginning!

The Best of the Best

It’s no secret, St. Simons Island pizza choices satisfy your cravings. There are some excellent restaurants to check out. Whether you’re seeking old-school Italian history or giving back to the community, there’s a pizza here for everyone.